Formative Assessment - Story Review

Analysis of the 2022 Film and 1930 Film Classic Version

"All Quiet on the Western Front," Erich Maria Remarque's iconic work, has been made into various movies throughout the years. A new anti-war classic was produced in 2022, and it has raised some issues about the film itself. Both films try to convey the horrors of war and anti-war sentiment.

The black-and-white film adaption, directed by Lewis Milestone in 1930, portrays the mood of the time. The limits of filmmaking equipment at the time, it is praised for its harsh realism. The performances, notably those of Lew Ayres as Paul Bäumer, are dramatic, conveying in anguish felt by troops during World War I. Milestone's picture was creative, receiving critical praise as well as the Academy Award for Best Picture at the time.

In comparison, the 2022 adaptation of the film “All Quiet on the Western Point”, has been directed by a new generation of filmmakers, with an advantage from high technology, which is I quite like the more visually striking battle scenes to much more special effects in this day of an era of film itself. The updated cinematography and sound design provide a raised sense of immersion. The choice to adapt the film in colour lends it a contemporary touch. Felix A.J. Weber, who plays Paul Bäumer in the 2022 version, delivers a compelling performance, reflecting the evolving understanding of war's impact on soldiers.

One of the most significant differences between the two adaptations lies in their temporal contexts. The 1930 version was produced not long after World War I, offering a more immediate connection to the historical events. The 2022 adaptation, on the other hand, is removed by nearly a century from the events it portrayed during the First World War. It offered a more reflective perspective on the long-lasting effects of war.

The 2022 remake has a more varied and inclusive cast, reflecting the changing environment of the film business and celebrating the service of troops from many backgrounds in World War I. This addition adds an element of complexity to the story and highlights the war's humanity. I found the plot was very moving where the German boys were looking forward to going to war, but the war changed them throughout both films. To take note, this is quite important for me to choose which film is "better" is largely the subject and depends on one's preferences. The public may claim that the 1930 adaption has a realism that cannot be duplicated, whereas others the 2022 version's visual and technical improvements.

In conclusion, "All Quiet on the Western Front" remains a timeless and essential story that speaks to the horrors of war. Both the 1930 and 2022 adaptations have their merits, offering different perspectives on the same narrative. The choice between them ultimately depends on one's cinematic preferences and whether they value historical authenticity or modern storytelling techniques. Regardless of the version, the message of the story endures, reminding us of the futility and human cost of war.